Redfin home price, sales and inventory figures run through October 2026. Other sources still update weekly. Why
Insurance Availability Stress by State
High premiums are the visible part of the homeowners insurance market. The bigger story for 2026 buyers is availability — carriers paused, FAIR Plans growing, non-renewal letters in the mail. This page composites NAIC pricing, FEMA hazard exposure, FEMA NFIP claim ratios, and curated carrier-pullback flags into a 0–100 availability stress score. Carriers run this analysis privately; here it is publicly.
States ranked by insurance availability stress
Score blends current price with carrier exit signals. CA / FL / LA are the obvious top tier. The next tier — coastal NC, wildfire-interface CO, tornado-belt OK — is where the next round of non-renewals will hit.
| # | State | Score | Status | Premium | Hazard | Recent FEMA | NFIP Claim Ratio | Carrier Pressure |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | California | 100 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $1,784 | Very High | 430 | 1.35% | severe |
| 2 | Colorado | 100 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $3,349 | Relatively Moderate | 172 | 1.87% | high |
| 3 | Florida | 100 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $4,231 | Relatively High | 1,021 | 2.00% | severe |
| 4 | Kansas | 100 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $3,931 | Relatively Low | 520 | 4.31% | moderate |
| 5 | Louisiana | 100 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $3,600 | Relatively Moderate | 1,141 | 5.74% | severe |
| 6 | Nebraska | 100 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $4,148 | Relatively Low | 385 | 3.29% | moderate |
| 7 | North Carolina | 100 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $2,074 | Relatively Moderate | 809 | 4.96% | high |
| 8 | Oklahoma | 100 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $4,334 | Relatively Moderate | 558 | 5.24% | moderate |
| 9 | Texas | 100 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $3,875 | Relatively High | 1,411 | 3.39% | high |
| 10 | Alabama | 94 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $2,738 | Relatively Moderate | 383 | 6.48% | moderate |
| 11 | Mississippi | 93 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $2,756 | Relatively Low | 776 | 5.66% | moderate |
| 12 | South Carolina | 88 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $2,297 | Relatively Moderate | 449 | 1.83% | moderate |
| 13 | Missouri | 86 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $2,417 | Relatively Moderate | 462 | 13.62% | low |
| 14 | Georgia | 82 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $2,330 | Relatively Moderate | 925 | 1.68% | low |
| 15 | Tennessee | 81 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $2,423 | Relatively Moderate | 741 | 3.59% | low |
| 16 | Arizona | 80 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $2,247 | Relatively Moderate | 106 | 1.03% | moderate |
| 17 | Kentucky | 80 | Severe — coverage hard to find | $2,624 | Relatively Moderate | 1,247 | 7.47% | low |
| 18 | South Dakota | 74 | High — carriers pulling back | $2,734 | Relatively Low | 388 | 5.24% | low |
| 19 | Arkansas | 73 | High — carriers pulling back | $2,562 | Relatively Low | 479 | 3.50% | low |
| 20 | Illinois | 72 | High — carriers pulling back | $2,087 | Relatively High | 249 | 8.34% | low |
| 21 | New York | 63 | Moderate — surcharges + restrictions | $1,844 | Relatively Moderate | 252 | 6.49% | low |
| 22 | Michigan | 60 | Moderate — surcharges + restrictions | $2,064 | Relatively Moderate | 260 | 3.87% | low |
| 23 | Minnesota | 59 | Moderate — surcharges + restrictions | $2,007 | Relatively Moderate | 339 | 6.83% | low |
| 24 | Washington | 59 | Moderate — surcharges + restrictions | $1,417 | Relatively Moderate | 352 | 2.43% | low |
| 25 | North Dakota | 58 | Moderate — surcharges + restrictions | $2,329 | Very Low | 288 | 6.70% | low |
| 26 | Montana | 57 | Moderate — surcharges + restrictions | $2,341 | Relatively Low | 234 | 2.53% | low |
| 27 | New Mexico | 57 | Moderate — surcharges + restrictions | $2,047 | Relatively Low | 205 | 0.77% | moderate |
| 28 | Oregon | 53 | Moderate — surcharges + restrictions | $1,327 | Relatively Moderate | 228 | 1.30% | moderate |
| 29 | Virginia | 51 | Moderate — surcharges + restrictions | $1,708 | Relatively Low | 572 | 3.03% | low |
| 30 | Indiana | 49 | Low — standard market accessible | $1,648 | Relatively Moderate | 398 | 4.64% | low |
| 31 | Pennsylvania | 48 | Low — standard market accessible | $1,443 | Relatively Moderate | 160 | 7.76% | low |
| 32 | Iowa | 47 | Low — standard market accessible | $1,843 | Relatively Low | 334 | 6.29% | low |
| 33 | Rhode Island | 47 | Low — standard market accessible | $2,301 | Very Low | 34 | 3.32% | low |
| 34 | Ohio | 44 | Low — standard market accessible | $1,516 | Relatively Moderate | 194 | 4.96% | low |
| 35 | Maine | 43 | Low — standard market accessible | $1,369 | Very Low | 678 | 4.01% | low |
| 36 | New Jersey | 43 | Low — standard market accessible | $1,530 | Relatively Moderate | 104 | 6.93% | low |
| 37 | Connecticut | 41 | Low — standard market accessible | $2,028 | Relatively Low | 69 | 5.56% | low |
| 38 | Wisconsin | 40 | Low — standard market accessible | $1,502 | Relatively Moderate | 199 | 3.94% | low |
| 39 | Massachusetts | 38 | Low — standard market accessible | $1,955 | Relatively Low | 56 | 4.31% | low |
| 40 | Maryland | 34 | Minimal — broad coverage available | $1,776 | Relatively Low | 75 | 3.32% | low |
| 41 | West Virginia | 33 | Minimal — broad coverage available | $1,494 | Relatively Low | 242 | 9.89% | low |
| 42 | Wyoming | 32 | Minimal — broad coverage available | $1,708 | Very Low | 59 | 1.50% | low |
| 43 | Alaska | 30 | Minimal — broad coverage available | $1,300 | Relatively Low | 181 | 1.69% | low |
| 44 | Nevada | 30 | Minimal — broad coverage available | $1,591 | Relatively Low | 118 | 0.94% | low |
| 45 | Idaho | 28 | Minimal — broad coverage available | $1,360 | Relatively Low | 129 | 1.07% | low |
| 46 | Utah | 28 | Minimal — broad coverage available | $1,210 | Relatively Low | 107 | 1.78% | low |
| 47 | Vermont | 28 | Minimal — broad coverage available | $1,120 | Very Low | 127 | 5.57% | low |
| 48 | Hawaii | 25 | Minimal — broad coverage available | $1,270 | Relatively Low | 43 | 2.12% | low |
| 49 | New Hampshire | 25 | Minimal — broad coverage available | $1,270 | Very Low | 47 | 3.74% | low |
| 50 | Delaware | 24 | Minimal — broad coverage available | $1,376 | Very Low | 11 | 1.79% | low |
States with active carrier pullback (2026Q1)
Verbatim signals we track. Add a state by editing src/lib/carrier-pressure.js and citing the DOI bulletin or trade press source.
- severe California. State Farm and Allstate paused new homeowners policies in 2023; Liberty Mutual and Farmers restricted; FAIR Plan exposure tripled 2018–2024. CDI moratorium on cancellations after major wildfires (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 10 § 2695.7).
- high Colorado. Wildfire-urban-interface counties (Boulder, El Paso, Larimer) see frequent non-renewals. Colorado FAIR Plan launched 2025.
- severe Florida. Largest insurer by exposure is Citizens (state residual market). 30+ carriers exited or were placed in receivership 2022–2024. SB 2-A 2022 reforms still settling.
- moderate Kansas. Hail / wind exposure; carriers shifting to wind/hail deductibles 2–5% of dwelling value.
- severe Louisiana. Multiple carrier insolvencies post-Hurricane Ida 2021. State Farm and Allstate pulled new policies in coastal parishes. Citizens-equivalent (LA Citizens) growing.
- moderate Nebraska. Hail-prone; rising premiums; some carriers reducing exposure in eastern counties.
- high North Carolina. NC Beach Plan / Coastal Property Insurance Pool growing; coastal county availability tightening 2023–2024.
- moderate Oklahoma. Tornado + hail capital — premiums highest in the U.S. and rising. Carriers restrict roof coverage to ACV vs RCV more aggressively.
- high Texas. Coastal counties pay 2–3x state-average premiums. Texas Windstorm Insurance Association (TWIA) covers Tier 1 coast as residual market; 2023–2024 capacity strained.
- moderate Alabama. Coastal Mobile + Baldwin counties via Alabama Insurance Underwriting Association (AIUA).
- moderate Mississippi. Coastal counties pay through Mississippi Windstorm Underwriting Association (MWUA) residual market.
- moderate South Carolina. SC Wind & Hail Underwriting Association covers coastal residual market.
- moderate Arizona. Wildfire interface counties (Coconino, Yavapai, Gila) seeing non-renewals; price increases 15–25% per year recent.
- moderate New Mexico. Hermits Peak / Calf Canyon fires (2022) resulted in carrier reassessment statewide.
- moderate Oregon. Wildfire risk maps + carrier pullback in southern + central counties (Jackson, Josephine, Deschutes) accelerating 2023–2024.
Method & honest limits
- Five-component composite. NAIC premium (vs $1,500 baseline), FEMA NRI hazard score (vs 50 baseline), FEMA recent disaster declarations, NFIP claim-to-policy ratio, and a curated carrier-pullback score from public DOI announcements.
- Carrier-pullback flag is curated, not feed-driven. No public API publishes carrier moratoriums in real time. Our
carrier-pressure.jsfile is updated when DOIs publish; PRs welcome via GitHub. - State-grain only. Carriers price + restrict by ZIP, distance-to-coast, distance-to-WUI, and roof age. A "moderate" state has high-stress and low-stress sub-state pockets.
- Excludes earthquake + flood as separate lines. CA earthquake is sold via CEA; flood by NFIP. Severe-stress states often require these on top of the homeowner line.
- FAIR Plan / state-residual coverage. When the standard market closes, FAIR Plans (CA), Citizens (FL), TWIA (TX coast), and similar state pools pick up. They cost more and cover less. A "severe" score implies you'll likely need one.
Sources: NAIC, FEMA National Risk Index, FEMA Disaster Declarations, FEMA NFIP, state DOI press releases. Carrier-pullback list maintained by HomeStats with citation.